Skip to content

James Buchanan vs Millard Fillmore

James Buchanan vs Millard Fillmore in 1856: electoral votes, popular vote and every state, side by side.

James Buchanan

Elections
1 (1856)
Won
1
Electoral votes, all runs
174
Best popular vote
45.3% in 1856
Parties
Democratic
vs

Millard Fillmore

Elections
1 (1856)
Won
0
Electoral votes, all runs
8
Best popular vote
21.6% in 1856
Parties
Whig-American
James Buchanan states
18
Millard Fillmore states
1
Popular vote
45.3% – 21.6%
Alabama: James BuchananAlaskaArizonaArkansas: James BuchananCalifornia: James BuchananColoradoConnecticut: another candidateDelaware: James BuchananDistrict of ColumbiaFlorida: James BuchananGeorgia: James BuchananHawaiiIdahoIllinois: James BuchananIndiana: James BuchananIowa: another candidateKansasKentucky: James BuchananLouisiana: James BuchananMaine: another candidateMaryland: Millard FillmoreMassachusetts: another candidateMichigan: another candidateMinnesotaMississippi: James BuchananMissouri: James BuchananMontanaNebraskaNevadaNew Hampshire: another candidateNew Jersey: James BuchananNew MexicoNew York: another candidateNorth Carolina: James BuchananNorth DakotaOhio: another candidateOklahomaOregonPennsylvania: James BuchananRhode Island: another candidateSouth Carolina: another candidateSouth DakotaTennessee: James BuchananTexas: James BuchananUtahVermont: another candidateVirginia: James BuchananWashingtonWest VirginiaWisconsin: another candidateWyomingVermont: another candidateNew Hampshire: another candidateMassachusetts: another candidateRhode Island: another candidateConnecticut: another candidateNew Jersey: James BuchananDelaware: James BuchananMaryland: Millard FillmoreDistrict of Columbia
Every state, 1856
StateJames BuchananMillard FillmoreGap (pts)EV
Alabama 62.1% 9 37.9% 24.2 9
Arkansas 67.1% 4 32.9% 34.2 4
California 48.4% 4 32.8% 15.6 4
Connecticut 43.6% 3.3% 40.3 6
Delaware 54.8% 3 43.0% 11.8 3
Florida 56.8% 3 43.2% 13.6 3
Georgia 57.1% 10 42.9% 14.2 10
Illinois 44.1% 11 15.7% 28.4 11
Indiana 50.4% 13 9.5% 40.9 13
Iowa 40.7% 10.5% 30.2 4
Kentucky 52.5% 12 47.5% 5.0 12
Louisiana 51.7% 6 48.3% 3.4 6
Maine 35.7% 3.0% 32.7 8
Maryland 45.0% 54.6% 8 -9.6 8
Massachusetts 23.1% 11.5% 11.6 13
Michigan 41.5% 1.3% 40.2 6
Mississippi 59.4% 7 40.6% 18.8 7
Missouri 54.4% 9 45.6% 8.8 9
New Hampshire 45.7% 0.6% 45.1 5
New Jersey 47.2% 7 24.3% 22.9 7
New York 32.8% 20.9% 11.9 35
North Carolina 56.8% 10 43.2% 13.6 10
Ohio 44.2% 7.3% 36.9 23
Pennsylvania 50.1% 27 17.8% 32.3 27
Rhode Island 33.7% 8.5% 25.2 4
South Carolina — — — —
Tennessee 52.2% 12 47.8% 4.4 12
Texas 66.6% 4 33.4% 33.2 4
Vermont 20.9% 1.1% 19.8 5
Virginia 60.0% 15 40.0% 20.0 15
Wisconsin 43.8% 0.5% 43.3 5

Questions and answers

Who won between James Buchanan and Millard Fillmore in 1856?

James Buchanan won the presidency. Electoral votes: James Buchanan 174, Millard Fillmore 8. Popular vote: James Buchanan 45.3%, Millard Fillmore 21.6%.

How many states did James Buchanan and Millard Fillmore each win in 1856?

James Buchanan carried 18 and Millard Fillmore carried 1.

Official results As published by The American Presidency Project (UC Santa Barbara) and the state documents it links. How we use this data